What Makes a Valuable Influencer - Seasoned Influence - Influencer Marketing For Food Companies

What Makes a Valuable Influencer

When you’re first starting out with influencer marketing, the task of finding the right influencers can be a daunting one. You might not know where to look (check out this post if so) or how to sort out the valuable influencers from the rest of the pack. Today we’re focusing on that second concern, showing you the qualities that make influencers valuable (or not). Let’s get started!

Audience size

We’ll start with audience size because it’s top on people’s minds and usually very easy to discern at a glance. We should highlight right off the bat, though, that it’s not the most important thing in determining an influencer’s value. In fact, micro-influencers (influencers who have a concentrated following anywhere from 5,000 to 50,000 followers) can be the most valuable to brands; we’ll talk more about why in the next section.

The more people you can reach with an influencer marketing campaign, the more effective it is, right? In reality it’s a little more complicated than that, but that doesn’t mean reach isn’t important! You likely won’t reach many consumers if you work with influencers with less than 5k followers, for example. On the flip side, you may not be able to afford the rates of macro or celebrity influencers who can have hundreds of thousands, or even millions of followers.

So pay attention to the size of an influencer’s following on social media, especially on those platforms you most want to focus on, but know it’s not the only deciding factor when assessing what types of influencers to work with. Between all the influencers you decide to work with, aim for a collective reach that’s as high as possible without exceeding your budget or compromising on audience engagement. Speaking of audience engagement….

Audience Engagement

Reaching a large audience is all well and good, but what makes an even bigger impact is convincing an audience to engage with the content that features your brand. An audience that engages with an influencer’s sponsored post is much more likely to absorb information out your brand, form opinions about your brand, repost or generate new content that features your brand, buy products or services provided by your brand, and in general give you a higher ROI, no matter what your goals are. To put it simply, engagement ensures the audience is not only seeing your post, as with reach, but also digesting that content, thus generating a higher awareness for your brand.

Micro-influencers (with an audience of 5k-50k followers) are likely to provide the highest audience engagement rates. Audience engagement tends to peak with a follower count within this size range for a few reasons. For one thing, these influencers can often better interact with their audience, and may appear more accessible and relatable to their audience. Their audience may feel a greater conviction that their comment, repost, or like will be seen, appreciated, and potentially responded to by the influencer. Their audience may feel a greater personal connection and therefore more loyalty towards these influencers.

No matter how large an influencer’s audience is, always take a moment to assess its level of engagement. The higher their rate of engagement, the better, of course. Influencers with smaller but more engaged audiences can be more valuable than ones with larger but less engaged audiences.

what makes a valuable influencer - audience engagementwhat makes a valuable influencer - audience engagementwhat makes a valuable influencer - audience engagement

History of Working with Brands

This may sound obvious, but let’s talk about it anyway: If other brands are choosing to work with an influencer, that’s a good sign that influencer might be worth working with. That’s not just because other brands have deemed this influencer valuable, but also because this influencer has had experience with these types of partnerships before. As a result, they may have a better sense of how to communicate with brands and generate quality sponsored content.

Still, you want to be mindful of how an influencer has worked with other brands in the past. Don’t assume that because an influencer has worked with brands before that this means they’re a good fit for you. Look at their posting history and ask a few questions: Does this influencer work with just any brand, or are they more thoughtful and selective of which brands they work with? Have they ever worked with a brand within your niche before? What is their ratio of sponsored posts to organic content?

Ultimately, you’re looking for someone who has proven that they’re able to work with brands, but isn’t indiscriminate about who they’re willing to work with and how often. If an influencer will work with anyone and rarely posts non-sponsored content, consumers may deem their endorsement inauthentic. We’ll touch more on authenticity later.

Content Quality

Nobody wants to work with an influencer only for the result to be utterly forgettable—or worse, actively unpleasant—content. A quick look through their posting history should be enough to assess their photography and/or video editing and composition skills. It should also be easy to tell whether they’re able to write clear and captivating copy accompanying their posts. Your influencers should be able to create content you’d be proud to have associated with your brand. They should be able to produce something you’d want to repost from your own social media accounts. Their content should be capable of catching eyes and directing interest to your brand.

Beyond quality, you should also assess whether the content is on-brand for you. If someone is creating content that is lighthearted and goofy, but you want your brand to seem elegant and sophisticated, that influencer may not be able or willing to create content that you’d be happy with.

what makes a valuable influencer - quality content


It’s crucial that an influencer give the impression of being genuine, honest, and trustworthy. The authenticity of an influencer is what makes influencer marketing so successful. According to Adweek, almost three fourths of all millennials and Gen Zers are opposed to being targeted by brands on their social media feeds (e.g. with traditional advertisements), but as much as 92% of them report that they are open to recommendations from influencers that they see as authentic. Consumers are increasingly savvy in spotting self-serving and disingenuous advertising, and more likely than ever to find it distasteful. But if an influencer can promote your brand with genuine interest and support, that can have a major impact.


So when it comes to choosing the right influencers for your next campaign, we recommend looking for influencers with between 5,000 and 50,000 followers who create excellent content (both sponsored and organic), communicate authentically with their audience, and generate engagement on their social media posts, especially in the form of likes, comments, and shares. If you need help connecting to influencers like these, we might be able to help! Shoot us an email and we can chat about how we work with brands to find the most valuable influencers for their campaigns.

No Comments

Post A Comment